You are not logged in. Please login or register.
MusicBrainz Forums → Feedback and Ideas → All instruments credit?
I was just fixing up some recordings and I ran into one where one artist is credited as performing "all instruments." The Wikipedia article doesn't stipulate what these instruments are; it just credits the artist as performing all of them. Do we have a special credit for this instance or do I have to put this in the annotation? I know of at least one other recording that has this same "all instruments" AR.
I would credit the artist as "Performed", and then note in the annotation the credit for All Instruments. I did something similar here:
http://musicbrainz.org/release/93097435 … 756ac3a873 though I was able to get a bit more info from the cd art.
The simplest solution could be to allow empty performed instrument(s) AR.
The simplest solution could be to allow empty performed instrument(s) AR.
That didn't work. It gave me an error message saying the specific instrument field was required.
Sure, that's why he said "to allow" - we don't now, but I'm not sure *why*.
Hoowee... back to this issue again.
I'm tempted to add "all instruments" to the instrument tree, but it's been hinted at in tickets like this that it might not be the way to go.
Thoughts/suggestions?
Ne has to write a RFC to the mailing list for this ticket you linked :/
He might already have, considering the age of the ticket.
I am the reporter of this ticket, and no, I have not written to the ML. :)
MusicBrainz Forums → Feedback and Ideas → All instruments credit?
Powered by PunBB, supported by Informer Technologies, Inc.
Generated in 0.065 seconds (76% PHP - 24% DB) with 10 queries